Average rating: | Rated 4.5 of 5. |
Level of importance: | Rated 5 of 5. |
Level of validity: | Rated 4 of 5. |
Level of completeness: | Rated 4 of 5. |
Level of comprehensibility: | Rated 4 of 5. |
Competing interests: | None |
This is an interesting, complete and well documented work. This study provides new light regarding the relative age and tectonic evolution (uplifting) of main lithologic units at North of Beirut (Harbour area).
The structure of this work follows a logical and clear order and the English is good. However, I advise the authors to include a new chapter about Materials and methods. In this chapter the authors should explain the location of the outcrops (UTM), sections thickness, treatment of the samples, etc. The introduction and the geological setting chapters are necessary. I’ve also suggest the authors to add synthetic figures (maybe at the corner of the field photos) showing the stratigraphic logs and the vertical position of the analysed samples. Despite I’m not an expert in foraminifera taxonomy, I think that the taxonomy of the foraminifera species here illustrated is correct.
The authors are able to clarify the relative age of the studied Cenozoic deposits in the Harbour of Beirut based on the foraminifera assemblage. Also they provide a detailed tectonic and paleogeographic evolution of the area during the Cenozoic. This study will serve as a reference for future developments of detailed geological maps and investigations focused on Lebanese basin evolution and carbonate characterization.
Few changes should be made basically in the figures. Please, find attached the PDF of the manuscript with my comments and suggestions.
Sincerely,
Dr. Josep Sanjuan Girbau