Background
Coronavirus is a large family of ribonucleic acid (RNA) viruses evolved from several animal species. They are generally RNA viruses (single stranded) responsible for causing different respiratory diseases [1]. Tyrrell and Bynoe [2] described the first strain of coronavirus. SARS-CoV-2 has been declared as a pandemic by the World Health Organization seeing the severity of infection and contagiousness [3]. SARS-CoV-2 has been proved to spread from human to human [4]. By controlling the source of infection, it can be prevented [5]. There are several ongoing therapies targeting the virus as shown in Figure 1. Extracorporeal therapies emerged as one of the treatments of this virus. This therapy constitutes plasma filtration, hemofiltration, hemoadsorption, and cell-based therapies [6]. Convalescent plasma therapy has also been used as a novel approach against this virus and proved effective in reducing symptoms and mortality [7]. In this immunotherapy, the plasma of donor (previously recovered patients of Coronavirus disease (COVID)) having antibodies transfused into COVID patient is used to fight against viruses, thereby helping to recover [8]. Recently, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) also emerged as an indispensable way to treat adults and children with pulmonary and cardiac dysfunction [9]. The latest advancements in ECMO involve spontaneous arteriovenous devices [10], and this technology is continuously improvising [11]. Several antiviral drugs, namely, remdesivir and favipiravir have shown their potential when tested against this virus [12]. Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) is another therapy that has been clinically proven to be effective in immunodeficient patients and showed encouraging results [13]. IVIg has found its place in the treatment of inflammatory and autoimmune conditions accompanying COVID-19 [14], and remodeling in its manufacturing process is made to increase its clinical efficiency [15]. A serine protease [tissue plasminogen activator (tPA)] [16] recently proved to be productive against COVID-19 [17]. Plasminogen was used to improve the conditions of COVID-19 patients with lung lesions, hypoxemia, and such related conditions [18]. The tPA (intravenous thrombolytic treatment) is explicitly intended for severely ill patients suffering from acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) [19,20]. Antibiotics such as azithromycin prevent to lower the respiratory tract illness [21]. Researchers are also exploring Teicoplanin (antibiotic) as a possible treatment of COVID-19 [22]. Micronutrients such as zinc (Zn) played a critical role in the management of COVID-19 [23,24]. Corticosteroids have also been tested against this SARS-CoV-2 infection and appeared promising [25]. Dexamethasone is recently emerged as another example in the class of corticosteroids which proved effective in reducing the mortality rate in COVID-19 [26]. Antimalarial drugs (chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine) showed an improvement in some parameters in COVID-19 patients [27]. Monoclonal antibodies emerged as a prominent class to combat this viral infection [28]. Interleukin (IL) 6 receptor inhibitor (tocilizumab) is found to be effective in ceasing cytokine flood in COVID-19 patients [29]. Pegylated interferon (alfa-2a, 2b) already approved for hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis C virus and also explored as a remedy against COVID-19 [30]. In this case series, we underlined several successful stories of COVID-19 explaining the use of amalgamated drug approach (Table 1) and probable role (Table 2). A literature search was performed using the keyword “COVID-19 successful case study,” “case study of COVID-19,” and “recovery from corona” in different scientific databases of PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science to obtain data pertaining to triumphant case studies.
Successful Case Studies of COVID-19
Various case studies mentioned herein this article describe only the overview of combinational therapy adopted depending on the patient medical condition. Detailed information about a particular case study can be accessed via reference mentioned.
Case study no. 1
A 60-year-old male having a medical history of multiple myeloma from China infected with COVID-19 was successfully treated with the use of tocilizumab (anti-IL-6 receptor antibody). The patient was administered tocilizumab (intravenously) after 8 days of hospitalization resulted in a gradual decrease in IL-6 levels [31].
Case study no. 2
A 23-year-old diabetic patient (type-II) working near Huanan Seafood Market, China, infected with COVID-19. During hospitalization, he was given meropenem, linezolid as antibiotics accompanying ganciclovir, and oseltamivir as antiviral drugs in addition to symptomatic treatment. He was recovered after 2 weeks of treatment [32].
Case study no. 3
Fontana et al. [33] accounted a successful case study of 61-year-old male having a previous medical history of chronic kidney disease (stage IIIa) with the administration of hydroxychloroquine, IVIg, and tocilizumab.
Case study no. 4
Zhu et al. [34] described the recovery of COVID-19 in a patient aged 52 years underwent renal transplant with methylprednisolone, IVIg, biapenem, pantoprazole, and interferon α. The patient was discharged after 13 days of hospitalization.
Case study no. 5
Liu et al. [35] also recorded a successful treatment of 50-year-old liver transplant recipient COVID-19 patient with combinational oxygen therapy along with antiviral (umifenovir and lopinavir/ritonavir), systemic corticosteroid (methylprednisolone), antibiotic (cefoperazone), IVIg, and α- interferon.
Case study no. 6
Mathies et al. [36] successfully reported a 77-year-old heart patient case study from Germany infected with SARS-CoV-2 with antimalarial (hydroxychloroquine), antibiotics (piperacillin/tazobactum and cotrimoxazole), and antiviral (ganciclovir) therapy.
Case study no. 7
Anderson et al. [37] recently described the use of convalescent plasma therapy, antibiotic (azithromycin), hydroxychloroquine, glucocorticoid with hydrocortisone, and antiviral drug (remdesivir) in management of a 35-year-old obstetric COVID-19 patient.
BOTANICAL NAME | FAMILY | ANTIVIRAL COMPOUND | ACTIVE AGAINST VIRUS | REFERENCE |
---|---|---|---|---|
G. glabra | Leguminosae | Glycyrrhizin | SARS-associated virus | [75] |
F. viridissima | Oleaceae | Dimeric lignans | Coxsackievirus rhinovirus 1B B3, human | [76] |
A. membranaceus | Fabaceae | Aqueous extract and methanol | Influenza virus | [77] |
Sophora flavescens | Fabaceae | Matrine-type alkaloids | HBV | [78] |
E. ebracteolata | Euphorbiaceae | Ent-atisane type diterpenoids | Human rhinovirus | [79] |
Eupatorium chinense | Asteraceae | Benzofurans | Syncytial virus | [80] |
P. sidoides | Geraniaceae | Prodelphinidin rich extract | Influenza virus | [81] |
Alchemilla vulgaris | Rosaceae | Ethylacetate extract | Ectromelia viruses | [82] |
Ilex asprella | Aquifoliaceae | Sulfur-triterpenoid containing saponins | Herpes simplex virus | [83] |
Saururus chinensis | Saururaceae | Ethyl acetate extract | Epstein-Barr virus | [84] |
Maytenus imbricata | Celastraceae | Proanthocyanidin | Mayaro virus | [85] |
I. indigotica | Brassicaceae | Bisindole alkaloids | Influenza virus, coxsackievirus B3 | [86] |
Illicium oligandrum | Schisandraceae | Spirooliganones | Coxsackievirus B3, influenza virus A | [87] |
B. var. marginatum stenophyllum | Apiaceae | Saikosaponins | Influenza virus | [88] |
Aloe hijazensis | Liliaceae | Anthraquinones | Avian avian paramyxovirus influenza virus type-type A 1, | [89] |
Illicium jiadifengpi | Schisandraceae | Sesquiterpenes | Coxsackievirus B3 | [90] |
R. nasutus | Acanthaceae | Naphthoquinone | Rhinovirus | [91] |
Erycibe obtusifolia | Convolvulaceae | Quinic acid derivatives | Respiratory syncytial virus | [92] |
P. ginseng | Araliaceae | Aqueous extract | Influenza A virus | [93] |
Wikstroemia indica | Thymelaeaceae | Biflavonoid | Respiratory syncytial virus | [94] |
Scutellaria baicalensis | Lamiaceae | Flavonoids | Influenza A virus | [95] |
Alangium chinense | Cornaceae | Sesquiterpenes | Coxsackievirus B3 | [96] |
Ziziphus jujuba | Rhamnaceae | Cyclopeptide alkaloids | Porcine epidemic diarrhea virus | [97] |
I. indigotica | Brassicaceae | Indole alkaloid | Influenza virus A | [98] |
P. lactiflora | Paeoniaceae | Paeonol O-galloyl-and β-D-1,2,3,4,6glucopyranose -penta- | Human rhinovirus | [99] |
Pueraria lobata | Fabaceae | Isoflavones, saponins | HIV-1 virus | [100] |
S. flavescens | Fabaceae | Alkaloids | HBV | [101] |
Although all the above cases of COVID-19 patients mentioned as case study no. 1 to 40 in Table 1 responded well when treated with requisite combination drug approach/therapy, but it still needs more clinical validation due to limited sample size.
CLASS OF DRUG/THERAPY | DRUG/THERAPY | PROBABLE ROLE |
---|---|---|
Aldose reductase inhibitor | AT-001 | Aldehyde reductase inhibitor |
Ampicillin | An irreversible inhibitor of transpeptidase | |
Azithromycin | Protein synthesis inhibitor | |
Biapenem, vancomycin, cefazolin, piperacillin cefdinir ceftriaxone, | Inhibits bacterial cell wall synthesis | |
Antibiotics | Cefoperazone, sulbactam, tazobactam | β-lactamase inhibitor |
Clarithromycin, linezolid | Inhibits bacterial protein synthesis | |
Cotrimoxazole | Blockade of folic acid | |
Levofloxacin, moxifloxacin | DNA gyrase inhibitor | |
Antimalarials | Chloroquine | Prevent viral entry |
Hydroxychloroquine | Interfere with lysosomal activity and autophagy | |
Arbidiol (umifenovir) | Antiviral (blocking trimerization of spike glycoprotein) | |
Darunavir | Antiretroviral medication | |
Antiviral drugs | Favipiravir Ganciclovir | Inhibits viral RNA polymerase DNA polymerase inhibitor |
Lopinavir/ritonavir | Blocks viral cellular entry | |
Oseltamivir, remdesivir | Inhibitor of viral replication | |
Corticosteroids | Ciclesonide, methylprednisolone dexamethasone, | Immunosuppressant |
Granulocyte factor colony-stimulating | Fligrastim | Regulates production of neutrophils |
Interferon | Peginterferon alfa 2a | Block viral replication inside cells |
IL receptor inhibitor | Tocilizumab | IL-6 inhibitor |
Anakinra | IL-1 inhibitor | |
Micronutrient | Zinc | Maintaining the immune system function |
Proton pump inhibitor | Pantoprazole | Inhibit gastric acid secretion |
Tissue plasminogen activator | Alteplase | Thrombolytic agent |
Vitamin | C (Ascorbic acid) | Antioxidant |
Convalescent plasma therapy | Antibodies patient transfused from the to blood the infected of recovered patient | Reducing cytokine storm |
ECMO | Works as an artificial lung (oxygenator) | |
IVIg | Exert immunomodulatory action by acting on different components of immune systems | |
Oxygen therapy | Use of oxygen as a medical treatment |
Case study no. 8
Lanza et al. [38] noted the recovery of a 42-year-old female patient with an earlier medical concern of hypothyroidism with hydroxychloroquine, azithromycin, and IVIg treatment.
Case study no. 9
Wang and Hu [39] accounted a recovery of 62-year-old male with a novel approach of extracorporeal blood purification (EBP). The patient was discharged on the 38th day from hospital.
Case study no. 10
Wang et al. [17] employed tissue plasminogen activator (alteplase) for COVID-19-related ARDS in a 59-year-old female having a previous medical history of hypertension from the USA.
Case study no. 11
Nakamura et al. [40] elaborated the recovery of a 45-year-old male from Japan with ECMO in combination with antiviral therapy (lopinavir/ritonavir). The patient was discharged on the 24th day from the hospital.
Case study no. 12
Tavazzi et al. [41] described a case study of a 69-year-old male resident of Italy having infected with COVID-19 with venous arterial ECMO.
Case study no. 13
Firstenberg et al. [42] recorded the use of ECMO in a 51-year-old female for successful treatment. The patient was discharged to rehabilitation on the 28th day.
Case study no. 14
Filocamo et al. [43] manifested the use of anti-IL-1 receptor antagonist (Anakinra) treatment in a 50-year-old male diagnosed with COVID-19. The patient was discharged on the 29th day from the hospital.
Case study no. 15, 16, and 17
Iwabuchi et al. [44] explained the recovery of three mild-to-mid stage COVID-19 patients with repeated use of inhaled corticosteroid (ciclesonide).
Case study no. 18 and 19
Ahn et al. [45] reported the recovery of two corona patients with an amalgamated approach of lopinavir/ritonavir, hydroxychloroquine, and plasma therapy.
Case no. 20, 21, and 22
Cao et al. [46] described the case studies of three COVID-19 patients recovered using a high dose of IVIg.
Case study no. 23
Millañ-Oñate et al. [47] described a recovery of a class-II obesity patient infected with COVID from Colombia with chloroquine and clarithromycin combinational therapy accompanying nutritional support.
Case study no. 24 and 25
Spezzani et al. [48] used amalgamated drug therapy for the successful recovery of married couple case suffering from COVID-19 infection.
Case study no. 26
Jahan et al. [49] represented a case of a 34-year-old male diagnosed with COVID-19 successfully treated with chloroquine and azithromycin. The patient was discharged on the 12th day from the hospital.
Case study no. 27
Coyle et al. [50] manifested a case of a 57-year-old male having the previous condition of hypertension was recovered by conjunction therapy of anti-malarial (hydroxychloroquine), antibiotics (azithromycin and ceftriaxone), corticosteroids (methylprednisolone), monoclonal antibody (tocilizumab), and aldose reductase inhibitor (AT-001). The patient was relieved from the hospital on day 19.
Case study no. 28, 29, 30, and 31
Finzi [51] proclaimed four case studies (different age groups) of the USA interestingly treated with oral administration of a high dose of zinc salts. This is an uncontrolled study, in which zinc lozenges were found to be effective in reducing symptoms of COVID-19.
Case study no. 32, 33, and 34
Lababidi et al. [52] described the recovery of three COVID-19 patients with combinational antiviral drugs (darunavir, ritonavir, and favipiravir), antimalarials (hydroxychloroquine), and peginterferon alfa 2a.
Case study no. 35
Bemtgen et al. [53] explained the recovery of a 52-year-old male by the combination of ECMO and percutaneous ventricular assist device (PVAD).
Case study no. 36 and 37
Wang et al. [54] described the recovery of two COVID-19 patients having mild symptoms of pneumonia from China with an amalgamated approach of oxygen therapy mechanical ventilation, antivirals, antibiotics, and a traditional Chinese medicine.
Case study no. 38 and 39
Ke et al. [55] represented a case study of two COVID-19 patients via blood purification technique.
Case study no. 40
Hartman et al. [56] showed the recovery of a 44-year-old male patient having the previous condition of hypertension with venovenous ECMO together with monoclonal antibody (tocilizumab) and high dose of vitamin C.
Other Alternative Approach
Several claims have been made in different alternative systems of medicine to treat COVID-19.
Huang et al. [62] reviewed several natural compounds (quercetin, andrographolide, glycyrrhizin, luteolin, emodin, and hesperidin curcumin) derived from plants with emphasis on Traditional Chinese System of Medicine targeting against SARS-COV-2. Nikhat and Fazil [63] described several Unani medicines as a preventive care in COVID-19. Tillu et al. [64] elaborated several methods as per Ayurvedic text in the prophylaxis of this virus. Kiran et al. [65] noted in silico screening of a Siddha formulation (Kabasura Kudineer) against COVID-19. Basu et al. [66] discussed several repurposed Homeopathic medicines in the management of SARS-COV-2. Keil et al. [67] recorded the use of ultraviolet light and riboflavin in the inactivation of coronavirus in plasma and platelet products via photochemical treatment. The use of ultraviolet light in air disinfection has also been explored as an approach to control the transmission of COVID-19 [68].
Nutritional support, in addition to various therapies for COVID-19, helps to boost early recovery and improvised immunity. Overall, it acts as a support system in virus treatment [69,70].
The concept of Universal antiviral vaccine [71], use of stem cell technology [72,73], and JAK (Janus kinase-signal transducer) inhibitors as an alternative approach for the treatment of this pandemic seems very promising [74].
Discussion and Author’s Perspective
Substantial efforts made by scientists and scholars all over the world in searching for the permanent remedy against this pandemic is highly appreciable, and we (humans) are very near in finding a ubiquitous solution. Plants have always been a source of inspiration for humans in drug discovery for years. They are eternally explored for their therapeutic potential. A large number of antiviral phytoconstituents present in plants might become suitable drug targets for Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 treatment. We are trying to highlight some of the plants exhibiting diverse antiviral properties with an emphasis on root part. There are many examples of roots as shown in Table 3 having antiviral properties such as Glycyrrhiza glabra which is found to be active against SARS-associated virus [75]. Astragalus membranaceus [77], Pelargonium sidoides [81], Isatis indigotica [86], Bupleurum marginatum [88], Panax ginseng [93], and I. indigotica [98] are proven to be competent against influenza virus. Forsythia viridissima [76], Euphorbia ebracteolata [79], Rhinacanthus nasutus [91], and Paeonia lactiflora exhibited a potential against rhinovirus [99]. Keeping in view the therapeutic potential of antiviral roots, these might serve as probable candidates to counter this dreadful virus.
BOTANICAL NAME | FAMILY | ANTIVIRAL COMPOUND | ACTIVE AGAINST VIRUS | REFERENCE |
---|---|---|---|---|
G. glabra | Leguminosae | Glycyrrhizin | SARS-associated virus | [75] |
F. viridissima | Oleaceae | Dimeric lignans | Coxsackievirus rhinovirus 1B B3, human | [76] |
A. membranaceus | Fabaceae | Aqueous extract and methanol | Influenza virus | [77] |
Sophora flavescens | Fabaceae | Matrine-type alkaloids | HBV | [78] |
E. ebracteolata | Euphorbiaceae | Ent-atisane type diterpenoids | Human rhinovirus | [79] |
Eupatorium chinense | Asteraceae | Benzofurans | Syncytial virus | [80] |
P. sidoides | Geraniaceae | Prodelphinidin rich extract | Influenza virus | [81] |
Alchemilla vulgaris | Rosaceae | Ethylacetate extract | Ectromelia viruses | [82] |
Ilex asprella | Aquifoliaceae | Sulfur-triterpenoid containing saponins | Herpes simplex virus | [83] |
Saururus chinensis | Saururaceae | Ethyl acetate extract | Epstein-Barr virus | [84] |
Maytenus imbricata | Celastraceae | Proanthocyanidin | Mayaro virus | [85] |
I. indigotica | Brassicaceae | Bisindole alkaloids | Influenza virus, coxsackievirus B3 | [86] |
Illicium oligandrum | Schisandraceae | Spirooliganones | Coxsackievirus B3, influenza virus A | [87] |
B. var. marginatum stenophyllum | Apiaceae | Saikosaponins | Influenza virus | [88] |
Aloe hijazensis | Liliaceae | Anthraquinones | Avian avian paramyxovirus influenza virus type-type A 1, | [89] |
Illicium jiadifengpi | Schisandraceae | Sesquiterpenes | Coxsackievirus B3 | [90] |
R. nasutus | Acanthaceae | Naphthoquinone | Rhinovirus | [91] |
Erycibe obtusifolia | Convolvulaceae | Quinic acid derivatives | Respiratory syncytial virus | [92] |
P. ginseng | Araliaceae | Aqueous extract | Influenza A virus | [93] |
Wikstroemia indica | Thymelaeaceae | Biflavonoid | Respiratory syncytial virus | [94] |
Scutellaria baicalensis | Lamiaceae | Flavonoids | Influenza A virus | [95] |
Alangium chinense | Cornaceae | Sesquiterpenes | Coxsackievirus B3 | [96] |
Ziziphus jujuba | Rhamnaceae | Cyclopeptide alkaloids | Porcine epidemic diarrhea virus | [97] |
I. indigotica | Brassicaceae | Indole alkaloid | Influenza virus A | [98] |
P. lactiflora | Paeoniaceae | Paeonol O-galloyl-and β-D-1,2,3,4,6glucopyranose -penta- | Human rhinovirus | [99] |
Pueraria lobata | Fabaceae | Isoflavones, saponins | HIV-1 virus | [100] |
S. flavescens | Fabaceae | Alkaloids | HBV | [101] |
Conclusion and Take Home Message
A lack of vaccine against COVID-19 resulted in the use of varying amalgamated drug therapies for treating this slayer virus. The rise of novel strategies on existing drugs opens new gates in antiviral drug discovery. The case studies of COVID-19 survivors mentioned in this paper will boost researchers working in this field and also motivates scholars working on different aspects of this virus. This petite case series encompasses around 40 triumphantly case studies that will definitely reflect the current achievements in controlling the pandemic all over the world. Although all cases of COVID-19 patients mentioned herein this article as case study no. 1-40 responded well when treated with requisite combination drug approach/therapy, it still needs further clinical and scientific validation due to insubstantial sample size.
What is new?
This article describes case series of COVID-19 survivors treated successfully via amalgamated drug therapies and different approaches adopted by physicians depending upon the patient medical condition associated with this virus. The literature pertaining to antiviral plants (roots) as probable candidate against COVID-19 mentioned herein this article may prove to curb the menace virus.