Stacked CMB lensing and ISW signals around superstructures in the DESI Legacy Survey

Abstract

The imprints of large-scale structures on the Cosmic Microwave Background can be studied via the CMB lensing and Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) signals, which are important cosmological probes. In particular, the stacked ISW signal around supervoids with extreme diameters has been claimed in several works to be anomalously high. In this study, we use four tomographic redshift bins with $0<z<0.8$ from the DESI Legacy Survey to find cluster and void superstructures, and measure the stacked CMB lensing and ISW signals around these objects. To compare our measurements with $\Lambda$CDM model predictions, we construct a mock catalogue with matched galaxy number density and bias, and apply the same photometric redshift uncertainty as the data. The consistency between the mock and data is verified via the stacked galaxy density profiles around the superstructures, and the numbers of such systems. The corresponding lensing convergence and ISW maps are then constructed and compared. The stacked lensing signal agrees with data well except for at the highest redshift bin in density peaks, where the prediction from the mock is significantly higher, by approximately a factor 1.3. The stacked ISW signal is in general consistent with the mock prediction. We do not obtain a significant signal from voids, $A_{ISW}=-0.10\pm0.69$, and the signal from clusters, $A_{ISW}=1.52\pm0.72$, is at best weakly detected. However, these results are strongly inconsistent with previous claims of ISW signals at many times the level of the $\Lambda$CDM prediction. We discuss the comparison of our results with past work in this area, and investigate possible explanations for this discrepancy.